HOA Landscape and Fence Approval in the Bitterroot Valley

Why do HOA landscape submittals get rejected?

Almost always for incompleteness rather than disagreement. A review committee is made up of volunteers working from a written set of covenants, and they cannot approve what they cannot picture. If the packet does not show where a fence line falls relative to the property boundary, or what a retaining wall will be built from, the committee has no basis to say yes and the safe answer is to ask for more information.

The second most common reason is a mismatch between what the covenants regulate and what the homeowner submitted. Many sets of covenants govern materials and colours in more detail than they govern plant selection, so a beautifully drawn planting plan that says nothing about the fence stain can still come back.

What does a complete submittal package usually include?

Most committees want the same core set: a site plan showing the property lines and where the work sits, elevations or product photographs for anything vertical, a materials and colour list, and a short written description of the scope. Where the project changes drainage or grade, they will usually want that called out explicitly.

Read your own covenants first, because they govern. What follows describes what these packets typically contain across the valley; it is not a substitute for your association's own submittal form, and specific requirements vary from one community to the next.

How detailed does a site plan need to be?

It needs to be measurable, not beautiful. A dimensioned plan showing the house footprint, the property boundaries, and the proposed work with distances from those boundaries answers most of what a committee will ask. Setbacks are the recurring sticking point; a committee has to know a fence sits inside the line, and an approximate sketch cannot demonstrate that.

If you have a plat or survey from your purchase, work from it. When a project runs close to a boundary and no survey exists, having one done is usually cheaper than the dispute that follows a fence built in the wrong place.

What do HOAs most often restrict on fences?

Height, material, colour, and how far forward of the house the fence may come. Many covenants treat the front and side yards differently from the rear, and some restrict solid privacy fencing in areas meant to read as open. Gate placement and whether the finished side must face outward also come up regularly.

Because these vary so much, the practical move is to identify the two or three restrictions that actually apply to your lot before you choose a design. Our custom fencing work usually starts with that conversation, and our guide to choosing the right fence for Montana weather covers how the material choices behave once they are in the ground.

How long does approval usually take?

Most covenants give the committee a defined review window, and many specify what happens if they do not respond within it. Find that clause and plan around it. The mistake is assuming a decision will come faster because the project seems small, committees frequently meet on a fixed schedule, so a packet submitted the day after a meeting waits for the next one.

In practice this means submitting well before you want to break ground. In the Bitterroot Valley the outdoor construction window is genuinely limited, and an approval that lands in October may push the work to spring.

Do you need approval for irrigation or lighting too?

Often yes, though less predictably than for fences. Anything visible from the street or from a neighbour's property tends to fall within review, which can include landscape lighting fixtures, above-ground irrigation equipment, and backflow assemblies. Purely underground work is more commonly exempt, but not universally.

Where the covenants are silent, asking in writing is worth the few days it costs. A written answer from the committee is protection later, and it is far easier to obtain before the work than after.

What if your HOA and the county both have rules?

You have to satisfy both, and they are independent of each other. An HOA approval is a private contractual matter between you and the association; a permit is a public regulatory requirement. Neither substitutes for the other, and clearing one says nothing about the other.

Structural elements are where this most often bites. A retaining wall, for example, can trigger a building permit based on its height and what it is holding back, our guide to retaining wall materials covers where that threshold falls in the City of Missoula. Confirm the requirements with the jurisdiction your property actually sits in, since city and county rules are not the same.

How do you keep a project moving while approval is pending?

Sequence the work so that anything not under review can proceed. Soil preparation, removals, grading, and irrigation sleeving under future hardscape are frequently outside the scope of a design review that is concerned with visible finishes. Getting those done while the packet is with the committee can recover several weeks.

The other useful step is to have the design resolved enough that an approval condition does not force a redesign. If you would like help assembling a submittal that answers the committee's questions the first time, our landscaping and design team does this regularly. Call HJ Property Care & Tree Service at (406) 493-8300 or request an estimate and we will walk the property with you.

More resources