HJ Property Care & Tree Service
Do your own lawn care or hire a program?
Lawn & Weed

Do your own lawn care or hire a program?

Reviewed by Adam Hurlbert, Owner & Founder, 15+ years in landscape & property care

HJ Property Care Team··5 min read·Last updated

Doing your own lawn care is fine when the lawn is small, weed pressure is light, and you will actually do the fall feeding and mow at the right height. A program is worth paying for when weeds have the upper hand, when you would rather not handle herbicides yourself, or when the timing keeps slipping. Montana State University Extension's basics are simple enough for most homeowners to follow. The real question is whether you will, and this page helps you answer it.

What does a Montana lawn actually need in a year?

Less than most product labels suggest, done at the right times. MSU Extension's guide to maintaining lawns in Montana recommends 2 to 4 pounds of actual nitrogen per 1,000 square feet a year, split into two or three applications so that no more than one and a half pounds go down at once. Its rules of thumb for timing are around Memorial Day, around Labor Day, and around Indigenous Peoples Day, after the last mowing and about four weeks before the soil freezes. If you only feed once or twice, MSU says the two fall applications are the key ones.

Mowing matters as much as feeding. MSU puts the best height for bluegrass, fescue and ryegrass mixes at 2.5 to 3 inches, says to remove no more than a third of the blade at a time, and says to leave the clippings, which return nitrogen and do not cause thatch. For water, it says to water in the early morning and as deeply and infrequently as the soil allows.

When is doing it yourself the right call?

When the lawn is small enough that spreading fertilizer takes minutes, weeds are scattered enough to pull or spot treat, you already own a spreader and a mower that cuts at the right height, and you will follow the calendar above. That describes a lot of in-town lawns in Missoula and the Bitterroot. If it describes yours, a program may be paying for something you can do in an afternoon or two a year. MSU also points out that it is often not necessary to control every weed.

Where do do-it-yourself lawns usually go wrong?

Mostly in timing and in too much of a good thing. Heavy nitrogen and frequent watering push soft growth, and MSU says most thatch problems come from that kind of overly vigorous growth. Overfeeding in fall is one of the practices MSU links to gray snow mold, the white webby patches that show up after snowmelt. Mowing short weakens the grass and opens the ground to weeds. Frequent light watering grows shallow roots and, according to MSU, favors weeds such as annual bluegrass and rough stalk bluegrass. And herbicides applied off label can damage trees, shrubs, flowers and the lawn itself, which is why MSU says to always follow the label.

When is a program worth paying for?

When weeds have taken over enough of the lawn that spot treating is not realistic, when noxious or hard-to-kill weeds are involved, when you would rather someone else handled and applied herbicides, when the calendar keeps slipping because life gets in the way, or when the property is a rental or a second home that nobody is at to look after. A program is also worth it when the lawn has a problem underneath the weeds, such as compaction or thatch, and you want it diagnosed rather than fed.

What does a do-it-yourself weed plan look like?

Start with the grass rather than the weeds. MSU Extension notes that weeds tend to grow where there is bare ground, thin turf or compacted soil, and that keeping a lawn healthy through watering, feeding, and aerating or overseeding thin areas is a way to prevent them. For the weeds already there, MSU says pulling, hoeing or digging them out before they set seed helps, and that plants which may already have mature seed should go in the trash rather than the compost. Herbicides are the next step, used by the label, on the weeds that cultural care and hand work do not handle.

What about the license?

The Montana Department of Agriculture requires anyone in the business of applying pesticides to hold an applicator's license from the department, and herbicides for weeds are pesticides. That requirement is aimed at people who apply them for hire, so it is a question to ask any company you hire. Whoever applies a product, including you, the label is the instruction to follow. Our questions to ask a lawn care company cover the license, insurance and re-entry.

Is there a middle ground?

Often the sensible answer is to split the work. Mow and water yourself and hire the weed control. Feed the lawn yourself in fall and hire aeration when the soil is compacted. Or hire a program for a season or two to get a weedy lawn back under control, then take it over. We offer recurring lawn mowing, fertilizer and weed control, and aeration and overseeding separately, so you only pay for the parts you do not want to do.

How do the costs compare?

Doing it yourself costs fertilizer, any weed control products, a spreader, your time, and the cost of mistakes, such as a scorched strip or a summer feeding that brings on disease. A program costs a set number of visits, with the product and the application included. The way to compare is to price the products for your lawn size against a written program quote for the same lawn. Our guide to what drives the cost of a lawn care program explains what moves a quote.

How do you decide?

Walk the lawn and be honest. If weeds are scattered, the grass is mostly thick, and you will follow the MSU calendar, do it yourself and keep the money. If weeds are winning, the lawn thins in the same places every year, or you know the fall feeding will not happen, get a program, or at least the part of one you will not do. If you are not sure what you are looking at, our guide to common lawn weeds in western Montana helps.

Next, read the questions to ask a lawn care or weed control company before you sign up, then see our fertilizer and weed control service or ask about a lawn program. You can also call HJ Property Care & Tree Service at (406) 215-7319. For the rest of the property, start with the Montana Property Care Guide.

Need help?

HJ Property Care & Tree Service is locally owned and ISA-certified. Call for a free estimate.

This article is part of the Montana Landscaping, Lawn & Irrigation Guide, our complete guide for western Montana property owners.

Explore our fertilizer & weed control.

Sources

We cite primary sources: Montana State University Extension, the City of Missoula, and the ISA, so you can verify anything here yourself.

  1. Maintaining Successful Lawns in Montana (MontGuide MT202004AG, revised 08/23) (Montana State University Extension). Last checked November 11, 2026.
  2. Commercial, Noncommercial & Public Utility Applicator Licensing (Montana Department of Agriculture). Last checked November 11, 2026.

Ready to transform your outdoor space?

Get a free, no-obligation estimate within 48 hours. Locally owned and ISA-certified.